Earlier this week, both Rich Harden and Aaron Heilman were claimed by other teams off waivers. Clearly, Harden is the better pitcher, and I think I can speak for most Cubs fans when I say I would love to have him back next year. However, trading Harden to a team desperate for pitching could reap a large reward for the Cubs. On the other hand, I think I can speak for most Cubs fans when I say just get Heilman the hell off the team. There is no way trading him will yield the Cubs anything valuable. With that said, let’s put them in the Fukudome.


VS.
Rich Harden Aaron Heilman

Which claimed Cub pitcher would you rather see traded?

View Results