For some reason, the Muskbox is mercifully short this week. Maybe Care Bear had something better to do. Like train her flying monkeys to attack that bitch from Kansas. Away we go.
I haven’t been able to follow the Cubs’ spring as much as I’d like to, being on the East Coast, but what are Koyie Hill’s chances of making the team? I know they have Paul Bako and I know how well he handles a staff, but Hill’s tearing it up. Can he handle the staff well enough to make the team?
– Mike J., Northbrook, Ill.
I get it. “HANDle the staff”! Ha ha ha! Because Hill cut off all his fingers with a table saw! Awesome! And then he made that deal with the Robot Devil for new hands, and started hitting everything the PCL! But those hands came at a terrible, terrible price, because the Robot Devil indirectly caused the love of Koyie’s life to go blind, so she couldn’t see his spectacular hitting. And then, the Robot Devil took his hands back. Or maybe that was an episode of Futurama.
CARRIE: Yes, Hill can handle the staff, and the pitchers like him. The pitchers also like Bako. Hill was batting .333 this spring, Bako .167 and Mark Johnson .091. That could be the deciding factor. And, I’m not a geography major, but Northbrook isn’t on the East Coast.
Me-YOW!
As of this point, what do you think the Cubs’ roster/depth chart will look like on Opening Day?
– Noah R., Glendale Heights, Ill.
It’ll probably be a list of twenty-five names with letters next to them symbolizing the positions they play. Sometimes, they will have the numbers of the jerseys of each player on it in a separate column. Perhaps they will even indicate whether the player bats or throws right- or left-handed. Maybe eleven or twelve of the players will be pitchers, and the rest will be position players.
CARRIE: Lou Piniella says he’ll make some final decisions by Thursday or Friday this week. But here’s a possible roster: Outfielders Alfonso Soriano, Reed Johnson, Kosuke Fukudome, Milton Bradley and Joey Gathright; infielders Aramis Ramirez, Ryan Theriot, Mike Fontenot, Derrek Lee, Micah Hoffpauir and Aaron Miles; catchers Geovany Soto and either Hill or Bako.
As for the pitchers, there are starters Carlos Zambrano, Ryan Dempster, Ted Lilly, Rich Harden and most likely Sean Marshall. As for the relievers, you’ve got Kevin Gregg, Carlos Marmol, Neal Cotts, Aaron Heilman, Chad Gaudin and two to be determined.
Carrie goes WAY out on a limb with the inclusion Joey Gathright. Bold. I’m still not convinced that Aramis is going to go north with the team. With Fontenot getting some reps in at third, and with the team wanting to get more left-handed, look for little Mike to beat out Aramis as the Opening Day third baseman. Also, how DARE she not mention Luis Viscaino as a lock for the Opening Day roster?
There’s a lot of rumbling about who will back up Ramirez at third. Is Bobby Scales getting much of a look? He raked at Iowa last year, and it seems he’s paid his dues. Oh, and the price is right.
– Chris S., Lincoln, Neb.
Okay, which one of you guys wrote this question? What “dues” has Bobby Scales paid? Enduring the awful torment of the guys on the bus to and from Iowa laughing at him and calling him “The Scales of Justice”? Because that’s just mean. Or maybe they called him “Grandpa,” since he’s going to be 31 years old this season.
CARRIE: Scales is one of many extra infielders in camp who are being looked at but hasn’t done enough, or else the team would not have added Esteban German and Corey Koskie. The Cubs also have Luis Rivas and Andres Blanco to consider.
Little does Carrie know that every single one of the guys she just mentioned is going to San Diego in the Peavy TradeTM.
CARRIE: When you look at the options, Hoffpauir is more likely to be the Cubs’ 25th man. The left-handed-hitting Hoffpauir can play first and the corner outfield spots, and they can use Aaron Miles as backup at third if needed. If Ramirez is sidelined for an extended period, Scales could get a call up. That’s why it’s so important for these guys to make a good impression this spring.
I was not aware that baseball players–nay, all professional people–are expected to perform well in order to get promoted to higher levels of professionalism. Thank God for you, Carrie. Thank God.
How does the unexpected early return of Marmol from the World Baseball Classic affect the closer competition in Spring Training? Will his performance against The Netherlands affect his chances at all?
– Keith B., Alburgh, Vt.
No.
CARRIE: That outing was a great test and something that can’t be simulated in Cactus League games. How Marmol bounces back will help determine whether he’s ready for the job. A closer has to have a short-term memory.
Carrie would make a great closer, then. She only wrote about the closer competition about a month ago, a couple weeks ago, and then again a couple days ago.
Carrie for closer!
With the fifth starting position still open, I was wondering what are the chances the Cubs would go after Pedro Martinez? He looked good in his outing in the World Baseball Classic, and I think he’s looking to join a contending team.
– Johnny P., Chicago
Even though it looks like Pedro is pretty well cooked, and even though I really want Marshall to finally get his shot, this question actually isn’t that stupid. They took a flyer on Ryan Dempster, a guy with a shitty track record, and that worked out well for them. It wouldn’t be THAT ridiculous to gamble that Pedro had a productive year left.
CARRIE: I’m sure he would, but I don’t see it. He’s 38, has had some health issues and the Cubs currently have better options in camp.
Like the NEXT Pedro Martinez, Angel Guzman! I’m glad Angel isn’t pulling his annual “Is this finally his year?” dicktease, as he’s racked up a 14.40 ERA in his 5 innings pitched this spring.

Nice Futurama reference, BK. If Paul Bako beats Koyie Hill out at this point, I have to assume he’s made his own side deal with the Robot Devil which grants him access to naked pictures of all the GMs and managers in major league baseball. It’s really the only explanation for why he continues to get major league work. I’ve been pulling for Hill since the off-season began and quite frankly, I don’t even understand why they even bothered signing Bako’s sorry carcass. Thank God Dusty Baker is with the Reds or there wouldn’t even be a competition. Hell, Soto might have lost playing time to Bako. Soto’s a kid and Bako’s a reliable veteran after all.
Northbrook’s not on the East Coast?
What dues has he paid??
How about being the goddamn Crash Davis of the PCL?
How about 3227 Minor league ABs and 992 games with an OPS of .801 while playing 40+ games at 5 different positions?
How about being Community Player of the Year multiple times?
How about the most dead-on impression of Tony Gwynn the world has ever seen?
I could go on and on…
How dare you speak of Bobby Scales in that manner.
Do you suppose Carrie had to check with Ed Hartig to find out that Northbrook isn’t on the East Coast?
I have never heard the slightest rumbling about who is going to back Aramis up at 3rd. I’ve always just assumed that if he goes down for any length of time, Hendry’s simple and elegant solution involves a locked room, a loaded gun and one last box of Krispy Kremes.
The most amazing thing is how closely Aldolf’s prediction of the 2009 Cubs Opening Day Roster on October 20, 2008 resembles the Muskrat’s current version.
For a reminder of what douchebaggery looks like:
http://www.bleedcubbieblue.com/2008/10/20/637547/building-a-cubs-champion-i